End animal scrambles in Maine

A scared animal. A screaming crowd. A tradition that Maine doesn’t need.

What you can do

Ways to help end animal scrambles

This campaign runs on public pressure. Pick one action below — or all seven — and speak up for compassionate treatment of animals and better lessons for Maine's kids.

01 Sign the petitions
02 Tell MAAF Leadership: It’s Time to Retire the Pig Scramble

The Maine Association of Agricultural Fairs (MAAF) sets the tone for fair culture across the state.

Other fairs have already shown this is an easy transition — in 2019, the Sonoma County Fair in California retired its pig scramble entirely, replacing it with a greased-watermelon obstacle course and a race featuring remote-controlled cars decorated like pigs. Kids still got the chaos and competition they love. No animal had to be terrified for it. Minnesota has gone even further: pig scrambles aren't even legal there.

Write, call, text, and email MAAF's leadership

Ask them to:

  1. Publicly acknowledge that pig scrambles are out of step with modern animal welfare standards
  2. Adopt a formal MAAF policy opposing pig scrambles
  3. Actively encourage member fairs to retire pig scrambles in favor of humane, animal-free alternatives — like Sonoma County's watermelon race, potato sack races, or other games that keep the fun without the fear

Contacts

Reach MAAF leadership directly

Please be respectful. Several contacts above are personal numbers and emails tied to individual farms and fairs, not MAAF office lines.

Ready-to-use language

Make your outreach count

Sample phone script

“Hi, my name is [name], and I'm calling because I care about Maine's fairs and I'm asking MAAF to retire the pig scramble. It's a stressful, frightening event for the pigs involved, and other fairs — like Sonoma County Fair in California — have already replaced it with humane alternatives like obstacle course races. I'd like to see MAAF adopt a formal policy opposing pig scrambles and encourage member fairs to do the same. Can you pass that along / can I leave my contact info for a follow-up?”

Sample text message

“Hi, I'm reaching out to ask MAAF to formally oppose pig scrambles at Maine fairs. Other fairs (like Sonoma County Fair) have already replaced them with humane, animal-free alternatives. Please consider a formal policy against them and encourage member fairs to retire them. Thank you.”

Sample postal letter opener

“I'm writing as a Maine resident/fairgoer to urge the Maine Association of Agricultural Fairs to formally oppose pig scrambles and encourage member fairs to retire them in favor of humane alternatives, as other fairs — including Sonoma County Fair — have already done successfully.”

03 Contact fairgrounds directly

Ask your fair's board to end pig and calf scrambles and commit to a fear-free fair going forward. Fair boards answer to their own communities faster than they answer to Augusta.

04 Contact your legislators

Ask your Representative and Senator to co-sponsor legislation ending pig and calf scrambles statewide, and to push the Joint Committee on Agriculture, Conservation and Forestry to support and lobby for its passing.

05 Leave pigs off your plate

Scrambles are only one way pigs suffer. Millions more endure intensive confinement and slaughter every year. Choosing more plant-based meals is one of the most effective ways to cut demand for that suffering — and it lowers your environmental footprint too.

06 Protest pig scrambles

It only takes a few people to organize a protest that gets attention and pushes fairgrounds to do better. We want fairs that are fair to everyone — make sure everyone knows it.

07 Donate to our campaign

Every dollar funds legislative outreach, veterinary coalition-building, and the ongoing care of pigs like Elle, Portia, and Joy — rescued from scrambles and now safe at Peace Ridge Sanctuary.

Pig scrambles, explained

What the heck is a pig scramble?

If you've never seen one, the name alone probably doesn't tell you much. Here's what actually happens — and why it's become the center of a growing fight across Maine and elsewhere.

01 The short version

A pig scramble is a fairground event where young pigs — often just weeks old — are released into a ring full of children, sometimes dozens at a time. The kids chase them down, grab them by whatever limb they can catch, and try to stuff them into a bag or sack before time runs out. Whoever catches a pig usually gets to take them home as a prize.

That's it. That's the whole event. The “sport” is built entirely on a young animal's panic.

Pigs are the most common target, but they're not the only one. Some fairs run the same event with calves, and others have used turkeys. Swap the species and nothing about the cruelty changes — it's still a young, frightened animal being chased down and grabbed by a crowd for entertainment.

Children chasing young pigs across a grassy fairground during a pig scramble.
A piglet attempts to flee during a scramble.
Two participants lifting a young pig toward a burlap sack at a fairground scramble.
Participants lift a piglet before shoving the animal into a sack.
02 What it looks like from the pig's side

Pigs are prey animals. Their entire nervous system is wired around one goal: recognize danger, escape it. A pig scramble delivers exactly the conditions that trigger that response — a loud, crowded, unfamiliar arena; a wall of strangers closing in; hands grabbing at legs, ears, and tails; and then confinement in a bag with no way out.

Veterinarians who've written in support of ending the practice describe piglets flooded with adrenaline and locked in flight mode for the entire event, vocalizing and struggling as they're carried off. None of that requires a broken bone to count as suffering — fear and acute stress are recognized welfare harms on their own.

03 What it teaches kids

Supporters call it a family tradition. Opponents — including the veterinarians, educators, and legislators backing this campaign — argue it teaches the opposite of what a fair should stand for: that the fastest way to “win” is to corner and physically overpower a frightened animal while a crowd cheers. Humane educators have pointed out that this kind of normalized rough handling in childhood doesn't build empathy, it dulls it.

04 It doesn't always end at the fair gate

Winning a pig isn't the same as being ready to keep one. Maine doesn't track what happens to a pig after the scramble ends — no follow-up on housing, veterinary care, or whether the family even keeps them. In practice, sanctuaries pick up the pieces every year. Peace Ridge Sanctuary alone has rescued four pigs won at Maine scrambles — Portia, Joy, and Elle, and Diana — after families realized too late that they weren't prepared for the space, cost, or years-long commitment a pig requires.

Sometimes it's worse than surrender. In 2016, three piglets won at the Houlton Fair were left in a locked car with no ventilation or water on an 83-degree day. One died of heat stroke; two others were injured. Even fair organizers elsewhere have had to admit the same pattern plays out season after season — pigs taken home by kids, then quietly handed off to sanctuaries once the reality sets in.

05 Is it even regulated?

Barely. In Maine, running a pig scramble requires a permit from the state's Animal Welfare Program — for a $10 fee. There's no routine state monitoring to check whether the rules that exist are actually followed, and no tracking of what happens to the pigs afterward. A permit isn't oversight — it's a rubber stamp.

06 Why now

This isn't a fringe position. Maine veterinarians, a forensic animal-cruelty researcher, a humane education nonprofit, and a New Hampshire state legislator who's already begun this fight in her own state have all put their names behind ending pig scrambles. Their argument is simple: fairs can absolutely celebrate agriculture, community, and childhood without frightening a young animal for entertainment. Many fairs already do.

Want to see the sources behind these claims, or hear directly from the experts? Check out the Myths & Facts and What the Experts Say sections of this site.

Why it matters

Cruelty isn’t entertainment

Pig, calf and other animal scrambles terrify young animals, subject them to rough handling, and put them at risk of injury. They teach children that bullying a vulnerable creature — causing them fear and pain for no reason — is just good clean fun. And every scramble desensitizes all of us a little more to animals and their plight.

Researchers Donald Broom and Andrew Fraser, in Domestic Animal Behaviour and Welfare, a standard reference in the animal welfare field, explain that welfare problems arise for pigs specifically when they can’t control events in their environment, when they’re frustrated, or when they’re subjected to unpredictable situations — the exact conditions a scramble creates.

The consequences are documented. Even fair organizers who defend the practice have had to admit its fallout: an August 13, 2026 Winchester Star article on a pig scramble in Virginia reported that two young participants from the year before were found failing to care for the pigs they’d taken home, and the animals had to be placed with sanctuaries — a pattern Peace Ridge Sanctuary sees firsthand every year.

When the scramble is over, many of the pigs “won” will end up living in inadequate conditions, abandoned to already inundated animal shelters or worse: slaughtered.

This is why Peace Ridge is working to end the cruel practice statewide. We will all — animals and people alike — be better for it.

Join us!

What the experts say

Don't just take our word for it.

Veterinarians, humane educators, Maine animal welfare organizations, forensic animal-cruelty researchers, legislators, and parents have put their names behind this campaign.

These are not “games” from the animal's perspective — they are episodes of genuine panic and distress inflicted on sentient, young animals for entertainment.

Dr. Elizabeth Stone, DVM, MS

Director, Community Spay and Neuter Clinic Maine / Center for Wildlife Health Research — Topsham, ME

Read Dr. Stone's full letter

This risks normalizing the idea that animals exist primarily as objects for amusement rather than as sentient beings deserving of humane treatment and respect.

Dr. Virginia Maxwell, Ph.D.

Professor of Forensic Science, University of New Haven — author, Investigating Animal Abuse Crime Scenes: A Field Guide

Read Dr. Maxwell's full letter

The fact that pig scrambles continue at Maine’s county and state fairs reflects a lack of understanding of an animal’s sentient nature, and promoting this cruel practice just “for fun” is damaging to children’s developing perceptions of the needs of other species and the development of compassion toward others.

In no world of animal care and use — whether agriculture, research, or within domestic settings — would such treatment of animals as occurs in pig scrambles be considered humane.

Dr. Victoria Hampshire, VMD

Bay Trails Farm, Surry, ME — 38 years in veterinary medicine; former USPHS veterinarian; humane consultant, Humane Society of the United States

Read Dr. Hampshire's full letter

The fear and distress experienced by the animals are real and avoidable... Entertainment and tradition do not justify subjecting animals to unnecessary fear, rough handling, or risk of injury.

The animals [are] being subjected to needless suffering purely for entertainment purposes. There is simply no reasonable argument that this serves any fundamental societal good.

As a veterinarian, I took an oath that includes the principle “first, do no harm.” I hope you will embrace this same sentiment and put an end to this cruel practice.

No farmer would ever mistreat a valuable livestock animal in such a way. Worse, the scrambles are teaching children that it is perfectly acceptable to torture an animal for human entertainment.

The meager entertainment value that some people might gain from it is outweighed by the suffering and terror inflicted on the piglets. It is additionally outweighed by the effect that the practice has on the developing human minds involved.

More letters from veterinarians, educators, and researchers are being added as the campaign grows.

Add your voice

Submit a letter from an expert

Email your letter of support and include your name, credentials, organization, and location. You can attach the complete letter directly to the message.

Submit an expert letter

A closer look

Myths & Facts

Pig scrambles have been part of some Maine fairs for generations, and plenty of people remember them fondly. That's exactly why they deserve a closer look — traditions that involve frightened, struggling animals don't get a pass just because they're old.

Here are the arguments people use to defend pig scrambles, and why they don't hold up.

Myth 01 “The pigs aren't hurt.”

They are. Some have died.

The absence of broken bones doesn't mean an animal hasn't suffered. Pigs are prey animals — their entire survival instinct is built around escaping predators. Being chased by dozens of strangers, cornered in a ring, grabbed, hoisted by a leg, and stuffed into a bag triggers the same panic response any prey animal feels when they're captured. Veterinary science treats fear and acute stress as welfare harms in their own right, not a footnote to visible injury.

And sometimes the harm doesn't stop at fear. In 2016, three piglets won at Maine's Houlton Fair were left in a locked car with no ventilation or water on an 83-degree day. One died of heat stroke. Two others were injured.

Even organizers who defend pig scrambles have had to admit the fallout. At Virginia's Clarke County Fair, organizers themselves acknowledged that two children who'd won pigs the year before were later found failing to care for them — the pigs had to be removed from their homes and placed with animal sanctuaries. Peace Ridge Sanctuary sees this same pattern every year: pigs won as prizes, then surrendered once the excitement fades and the reality of raising a pig sets in.

“The pigs aren't hurt” isn't a fact. It's a hope — repeated by people who don't follow what happens after the ring empties.

Myth 02 “The pigs enjoy it.”

There's no evidence for that, and everything we know about pig behavior points the other way. Pigs avoid unfamiliar people, flee from perceived threats, vocalize when frightened, and struggle when restrained. If someone insists the pigs are “having fun,” the burden of proof is on them — not on the veterinarians and behaviorists whose research shows pigs experience fear much like dogs do.

Myth 03 “Kids learn responsibility.”

Responsibility is learned by caring for animals, not overpowering them. Kids can build compassion and good husbandry skills by feeding animals, cleaning enclosures, or volunteering with a sanctuary or wildlife rehabber. A pig scramble teaches something else entirely: that the fastest way to win is to chase down and physically overpower a frightened animal while adults cheer. That's not a value worth celebrating.

Myth 04 “It's harmless fun.”

It's exciting for the crowd because it's terrifying for the pig. Kids run, adults cheer, and the pig tries desperately to get away — the whole spectacle depends on the pig's unwilling participation. If the pig calmly walked over to a child, there'd be no scramble at all.

Myth 05 “It's a tradition.”

Plenty of practices involving animals were once defended as tradition before society reconsidered them. The question isn't whether pig scrambles are old. It's whether frightening young animals for entertainment is something Maine wants to keep celebrating.

Myth 06 “The pigs are headed for slaughter anyway.”

An animal's eventual fate doesn't justify frightening or mishandling them today. Maine has humane-care laws for farmed animals precisely because their welfare matters regardless of what happens to them later. A pig scramble adds fear without serving any legitimate agricultural purpose.

Myth 07 “This teaches kids about agriculture.”

Fact: Even by agriculture's own stated standards, this fails. Calm, humane handling is supposed to be the goal — not the exception — because frightened animals suffer more and are harder to manage. Pig scrambles don't aim for that standard; they treat an animal's fear as entertainment. If this is a lesson, it's the wrong one.

Myth 08 “Most pigs go to good homes.”

No one actually knows. Maine's permit system doesn't track pigs after they leave the fairgrounds — no agency checks whether the family kept the pig, provided proper housing or vet care, surrendered them, or abandoned them. What we do know: every summer and fall, sanctuaries like Peace Ridge get calls from people who “won” a pig at a scramble and can't keep them. Portia, Joy, and Elle all ended up at Peace Ridge this way — each treated as a prize before becoming someone else's problem. Without tracking, claims about “most” pigs are speculation, not evidence.

Myth 09 “There are rules, so the pigs are protected.”

Rules only matter if they're enforced. Maine requires a permit, but there's no routine state monitoring to check whether fairs actually follow it. A permit is not oversight.

Myth 10 “Only animal rights activists oppose this.”

Opposition includes veterinarians, animal behaviorists, humane educators, forensic cruelty researchers, sanctuaries, concerned parents, former participants, legislators, and plenty of ordinary Mainers who think kids deserve better lessons and animals deserve better treatment.

Myth 11 “It's only a few minutes.”

Duration doesn't determine whether suffering matters. A dog left in a hot car for five minutes can still suffer. A deer chased briefly by a predator still experiences real fear. A pig chased, restrained, and carried off can experience intense distress in that same short window. Welfare is measured by what the animal experiences, not by the clock.

Myth 12 “Without pig scrambles, fairs will disappear.”

Fairs across North America thrive without them. People come for livestock shows, food, music, rides, and community — not because children are chasing terrified animals. Ending pig scrambles doesn't threaten Maine's fairs. It just makes them more humane.

Every generation decides which traditions are worth keeping. We believe Maine can celebrate agriculture, childhood, and community without frightening young animals for entertainment.